Important South African and International Art

Live Auction, 9 November 2015

Session 2

Sold for

ZAR 591 136
Lot 258
  • Robert Hodgins; A Colloquy of Scoundrels


Lot Estimate
ZAR 500 000 - 700 000
Selling Price
Incl. Buyer's Premium & VAT
ZAR 591 136

About this Item

South African 1920-2010
A Colloquy of Scoundrels

signed, dated 1999, inscribed with the title and medium on the reverse

oil on canvas
91 by 122cm excluding frame

Notes

In the 2002 monograph edited by Brenda Atkinson, still the seminal work on Hodgins, essayist and critic Ivor Powell selects A Colloquy of Scoundrels as a “relatively random example” to represent central and important themes in Hodgins’ouvre.1 He argues particularly that ambiguity is the definitive characteristic of Hodgins’ work, and central to the effect it produces.

“[T]he heads of the three figures in  A Colloquy of Scoundrels only just cross the threshold from being meaningless blobs to acquiring human identity. They do this by the merest hints: the vaguest of shading for features; the most rudimentary of dots of eyes; and the crudest of lines that could be picking out collars (or maybe not).”2

A Colloquy of Scoundrels is typical of Hodgins’ post-apartheid “humorous mode of critique”, as Sue Williamson puts it, rather than his earlier, darker, more “acerbic ... critiques of power”.3 The three figures belong to his “endlessly circulating retinue of fools for mocking”: the businessmen in striped suits, politicians, military men and various others operating in the boys’ clubs and corridors of power.4 These scoundrels’ red cloak-like clothing suggests that they are cardinals, adding the Catholic church to the list of men in positions of institutional power Hodgins depicts.

The way they huddle suggests scheming and plotting rather than the true definition of a colloquy (“an informal conference on religious or theological matters”).5 Their villainy is most obviously suggested in the way the red paint of their cloaks dribbles like blood, but as in many of Hodgins’ works, the disfigurement of their heavy-limbed bodies and formless features convey corruption, cruelty and the humanity’s basest impulses.

Their indistinct features, which seem momentarily identifiable and then swim back into abstraction, however, are what interest Powell most. Hodgins’ figures are not so much depictions as evocations: a combination of semi-abstract, semi-surrealist forms that “creates tensions of possibility and virtuality, provoking the viewer to fill the canvas with associations, connections, subliminal and half-raised ‘textlets’ of his or her own.6

With particular reference to A Colloquy of Scoundrels, he notes how the minimal information provided by the almost-formless figures, which see-saw between representation and abstraction “becomes eloquent of the secrecy and shiftiness of the huddle”.7 The way in which the formal ambiguity of this work dovetails with its particular subject to produce its effect, rather than being merely typical of Hodgins’ work, can be seen as exemplary.

1. Ivor Powell. (2002) ‘Through Ubu’s eyes: Ambiguity in Hodgins’ in Robert Hodgins, Cape Town: Tafelberg Publishers. Page 49.
2. Ibid.
3. Sue Williamson. (2009) ‘Robert Hodgins’ in South African Art Now, New York: Collins Design. Page 186.
4. Ibid.
5. Collins English Dictionary - Complete & Unabridged 10th Edition. HarperCollins Publishers.
6. Ivor Powell. (2002) ‘Through Ubu’s eyes: Ambiguity in Hodgins’ in Robert Hodgins, Cape Town: Tafelberg Publishers. Page 44.
7. Ivor Powell. (2002) ‘Through Ubu’s eyes: Ambiguity in Hodgins’ in Robert Hodgins, Cape Town: Tafelberg Publishers. Page 49.

Literature

Fraser, Sean (ed.) (2002) Robert Hodgins, Tafelberg: Cape Town. Illustrated in colour on page 49.

View all Robert Hodgins lots for sale in this auction


Other lots that might interest you
Penny Siopis; Honour
Penny Siopis
Honour
ZAR 20 000 - 30 000
Robert Hodgins; Tailor Made...
Robert Hodgins
Tailor Made...
ZAR 18 000 - 24 000
Gregoire Boonzaier; Straat met Donkiekar en Tafelbaai, Dist. Ses, Kaapstad
Gregoire Boonzaier
Straat met Donkiekar en Tafelbaai, Dist. Ses, Kaapstad
ZAR 100 000 - 150 000
Gerard Sekoto; Senegalese Street Scene
Gerard Sekoto
Senegalese Street Scene
ZAR 200 000 - 300 000
Norman Catherine; Performance
Norman Catherine
Performance
ZAR 300 000 - 400 000
Norman Catherine; Vengeance is Mine
Norman Catherine
Vengeance is Mine
ZAR 200 000 - 300 000